Workers Comp Audit: What the Auditor Checks and How Contractors Avoid a Surprise Bill
A contractor called us last week with a fair question. He had more guys on the payroll for a few days than he planned. "If I go over my number for three days, are they going to charge me that rate for the whole year?"
No. But the question tells you how most contractors feel about a workers comp audit. It shows up after the policy ends, nobody explains it, and sometimes it ends with a bill nobody saw coming. Here is how the audit actually works, what the auditor looks at, and how to keep the number at the end of the year close to the number you budgeted.
What a workers comp audit is
Your workers comp premium starts as an estimate. When the policy is written, the carrier prices it on the payroll you expect to pay, split by the type of work your people do. That estimate is a guess made a year ahead of time.
The audit is the carrier checking the guess against what really happened. After the policy term ends, an auditor looks at the payroll you actually paid during that term, in each job classification. The carrier then recalculates the premium on the real numbers.
If you paid less payroll than estimated, you can get money back. If you paid more, you owe the difference. That is the whole idea. It is not a penalty and it is not an investigation. It is a true-up.
So what about those three busy days?
Comp premium is figured on payroll, not on headcount by the day. The rate for each class is applied to every $100 of payroll paid in that class. Three days of extra payroll adds three days of extra payroll to the total. It does not reset your rate for the year. The carrier just charges premium on the extra dollars you actually paid.
What the auditor checks
Most workers comp audits come down to four things.
1. Total payroll for the policy period
The auditor wants payroll for the exact policy dates, not your calendar year. If your policy runs April to April, your December payroll report will not line up on its own. Expect to provide quarterly payroll tax filings, your payroll journal or summary, and often your general ledger.
2. Which class code each person's pay belongs in
Every type of work has a class code with its own rate. A roofer's code costs far more than a clerical code. If an employee does office work and field work, how their payroll is split matters, and the rules on splitting payroll vary by state. If your records don't show the split clearly, the auditor may put the whole payroll in the higher-rated code.
3. Subcontractors and their certificates
This is where the surprise bills come from. When you pay a subcontractor who does not carry their own workers comp, many carriers will count what you paid that sub as payroll on your policy. That is because if the sub's worker gets hurt on your job, your policy can end up paying for it.
The fix is simple and boring: collect a current certificate of insurance from every sub before they start, and keep it on file for the whole policy period. A certificate that expired in the middle of the job can be a problem too.
Whether someone you pay is an employee or a true independent contractor is set by state law, and the tests differ from state to state. We don't make that call. If you are unsure how someone should be classified, talk to an employment attorney.
4. Owners and officers
Some states let owners or corporate officers exclude themselves from coverage, and some include them at a set payroll amount. If you are an owner who works in the field, confirm with us how you are set up on the policy before the audit, not during it.
General liability, workers comp, commercial auto, equipment - we package the whole program for contractors. Apply in about 10 minutes and we will get to work.
Types of audits
- Mail or online audit. You fill out a form and send copies of your records. Common for smaller policies.
- Phone or virtual audit. An auditor walks through your records with you on a call or video meeting.
- Field audit. An auditor visits in person. More common on larger policies, or when the carrier has questions.
Whatever the type, don't ignore it. If you don't complete the audit, carriers can bill you an estimated premium, which is often higher than the real number, and they can cancel or non-renew the policy. An unfinished audit can also follow you when you shop for coverage the next year.
Switched carriers or closed the business? You still owe the audit
We hear this one a lot: "I don't even have that policy anymore." The audit is still part of the deal you made when you bought the policy. The carrier priced it on an estimate, and you agreed to report the real numbers at the end. If you skip it, the carrier can bill you the estimated premium anyway, and an unpaid audit bill can go to collections even if you are no longer insured with them.
What to do when the audit request shows up
- Find the request. It can come by email, phone or regular mail, from the carrier or from a third-party audit company working for them. If you aren't sure it's real, call us and we'll confirm it.
- Read the list of what they want. For workers comp that usually means payroll reports, your quarterly 941s and your state wage reports for the policy period. If your general liability is rated on payroll or sales, expect to provide your profit and loss statement for the same dates.
- Pull your sub certificates. For every subcontractor you used, have a certificate that covers the dates they worked for you during your policy period.
- Set aside an hour or two. Many audits are done online now. Enter the numbers, upload the documents, and keep a copy of everything you send.
- Send us the result before you pay. We'll check it for wrong class codes or subs counted by mistake.
How contractors avoid a surprise audit bill
Tell us when payroll changes
If you land a big job and staff up, call us. We can ask the carrier to update the payroll estimate on the policy mid-term. You pay a little more as you go instead of all of it at once at audit time. The same works in reverse. If work slows down, lowering the estimate can lower your installments.
Ask about pay-as-you-go
Some carriers offer pay-as-you-go workers comp, where premium is billed off each payroll run. Your premium follows your real payroll all year, so the audit has much less to adjust. It is not available everywhere or for every class, but it is worth asking about if your payroll swings a lot.
Keep payroll records the way an auditor reads them
- Track hours by type of work for anyone who does more than one kind.
- Show overtime separately. In many states the extra pay for overtime (the "half" in time-and-a-half) can be left out of comp payroll, but only if your records show it.
- Keep a certificate file for every sub, with dates that cover the whole time they worked for you.
- Match your records to the policy dates, not just the calendar year.
Review the audit before you pay it
Auditors make mistakes. Wrong class codes, subs counted without checking certificates, overtime counted at full pay. When the audit comes back, send it to us before you pay it. If something is wrong, the carrier has a process to dispute it, and most states have a review process through the rating bureau or the insurance department if you can't settle it with the carrier.
A workers comp audit is a bonding issue too
If you work bonded jobs, a big audit bill hits more than your bank account. Sureties read your financial statements, and a surprise bill late in the year eats working capital, which is one of the numbers they watch most. Keeping your comp estimate close to real payroll is part of keeping your bonding capacity where you need it. If you want to see where you stand, the Bond Scorecard takes a few minutes.
Frequently asked questions
When does a workers comp audit happen?
Usually after the policy term ends, often within a few months. Some carriers also do interim audits during the term, especially on larger or fast-growing accounts.
Can I get money back from a workers comp audit?
Yes. If your actual payroll came in lower than the estimate, the recalculated premium is lower and the carrier owes you a return premium, subject to any minimum premium on the policy.
Do I pay workers comp on 1099 subcontractors?
If the sub carries their own workers comp and you have a current certificate, their pay is generally not added to your policy. If they don't, many carriers will count it as your payroll. Whether a person is a true independent contractor is a state law question. Ask an employment attorney.
What happens if I don't complete my audit?
The carrier can bill an estimated premium, which is often higher than your real number, and can cancel or non-renew your coverage. Completing the audit is almost always cheaper.
Can I dispute my audit results?
Yes. Start with the carrier, with your records in hand. If you can't resolve it there, most states have a formal review process. We help clients through this.
Get your next audit right before it starts
The Grit team works with contractors on their comp program all year, not just at renewal. We set the payroll estimate with you, check your class codes, and review your audit before you pay it. Call us at (801) 505-5500 or start at gritinsurance.com.
Rules on overtime, owner coverage, payroll splits and audits vary by state and carrier. This article is general information, not advice for your policy. Talk to a licensed Grit team member about your situation.